The difference between China’s 17th Karmapa and HHK16’s Karma Kagyu crazy widsom lineage in the West

China, ruled by a dictatorship since the Communists seized power in 1949, that which the 16th Karmapa escaped in 1959 in search of the freedom to practice his particular lineage of Buddhism in the West, the dictatorship of the Chinese Communist party being incompatible with his lineage of Buddhism as such, is something we in the West take this to be self evident.

For us the Karma Kagyu lineage that Rangjung Rikpe Dorje established in the West in the 1970’s represents a return to the Buddhism of India before thr sacking of Nalanda in the 13th century by the Muslim Malmuk Dynasty and its masters of Mahamudra, specifically the lineage of Maitripa as brought to Tibet by Marpa the translator in the early days of Buddhism there, with its emphasis on Buddha nature and the recognition of the true nature of the mind.

We can’t get enough of these teachings in the West.

After His Holiness passed into Parinirvana here in 1981, his choice, against the wishes of his Tibetan followers of the day, specifically Thrangu, Akong, and Khenpo Karthar Rinpoches, in the name of preserving Tibetan tradition chose to collaborate with the Chinese to make Tibet, as part of China, great again, to borrow a phrase from Donald Trump and his followers whom like our Rinpoches saw their future best served by dictatorship rather than democracy.

Birds of a feather flock together.

In the future when the history of what became of the Tibetan people is written, when there are no Tibetans left free to speak for themselves other than China’s version of a Tibetan, it will record that the Tibetan people chose the dictatorship they know, life under the rule of Chinese Communist Party, over the freedom they balked at embracing, life in the West.

My history as a Karma Kagyu begins in 1981 when I took refuge with Khenpo Karthar Rinpoche, a lama of the 16th Karmapa sent to us in 1976 to represent his interests in North America, not so much as a teacher as much as a response to our enthusiasm for the teachings of Chogyam Trungpa Rinpoche whom introduced us beginning in 1970 to his Indian Mahasiddha inspired crazy wisdom Karma Kagyu lineage, which as it turned out was not representative of the Buddhism practiced by Tibetans living in exile at Rumtek Monastery in the Sikkim, India, the monastic seat in exile of the Karma Kagyu sect of Tibetan Buddhism.

Suffice it to say I am a witness of that which I speak of, what happened from the collaboration of Thrangu, Akong, and Khenpo Karthar Rinpoche with the Chinese Communist Party’s United Front Work Department which began with Akong Rinpoche’s first visit to Chinese occupied Tibet in 1983 to present, the coming of age of China’s 17th Karmapa, Ogyen Trinley Dorje, and his Chinese followers we in the West so oppose not just for their spiritual materialism, to borrow a phrase from Chogyam Trungpa Rinpoche, but also for their lack of representativeness,
transparency, and accountability, that which we find so offensive as dharma practitioners living in Western democracies as opposed to dictatorship as a matter of principle.

Unlike as with Ogyen Trinley Dorje and his Chinese followers, for us the arc of human history bends not towards dictatorship but instead to democracy.

This is our story.

I’m just recently retired.

My wife was an editor at McGraw-Hill like forever, the only job she ever had since graduating college, up until she stopped working two years ago.

At 60 ears old she was reorganized out of her livelihood

We’ve been married 13 years, the past 10 years of which I’ve been in retreat, for lack of a better word to describe my decision to stop working and focus my efforts on my dharma practice.

I’m a lama.

For the past two years our expectation was that my wife would continue her career in publishing as an editor but sadly there isn’t much demand for people with here level of experience as a publishing professional, other than as a freelance project manager, which simply isn’t the same career wise.

The day my wife stopped working was the end of my retreat.
For eight years my day was mine to drill down into my practice while my wife was at work.

It has taken me two years to adjust to my post retreat existence.

In 2010 Waylon Lewis, publisher of Elephant Journal, asked me to write for him.

I was dying at the time.

I was collecting dharma quotes and posting them to Twitter to
pass the time when Waylon Lewis reached out to me.

It gave me a reason to get out of bed and sit in chair for a couple of hours.

I kid you not.

My prognosis could not have been worse.

In 2009 I survived the widow-maker.

That I survived what I did was a miracle in itself.

I meditated through it.

I was walking, I stopped, sat down, crossed my legs and began doing mani recitations while visualizing Amitabha, as outlined in Karma Chakme’s the Union of Dzogchen and Mahamudra, a favorite teaching of mine being Khenpo Karthar’s teaching of the text.

I highly recommend the practice.

Without it I doubt I would be alive today.

One day, Marvin Moser, a lama friend of mine reached out to me and asked me to blog about KTD’s banishment of Bardor Rinpoche.

As a KTD lama at the time, he paid for his robes, did his three year retreat with Khenpo Karthar Rinpoche at Karme Ling, the first of us here in Chicago to go there, he was one very unhappy camper.

He has since put his robes in a drawer and put the experience behind him.

At the time though he had a lot vested in KTD, not just as a retreat lama, but as a longtime financial contributor to the place since the early 1980’s.

I checked out what he had told me had happened.

All I had to do is say I’m a friend of Marvin’s.

This was my first encounter with the machinations of Ogyen Trinley Dorje and his Chinese followers that have taken over KTD since the early 1990’s and it was a revelation for me as a dharma practitioner.

Long story short, in 2008 Tenzin Chonyi, President of KTD fired the facilities manager for not mowing his lawn.

I kid you not.

Bardor Tulku took exception to this.

Khenpo Karthar agreed.

Both Rinpoches asked Tenzin Chonyi to reinstate the terminated facilities manager.

He refused.

Bardor Tulku demanded Tenzin Chonyi’s resignation.

Tenzin Chonyi refused.

The matter was kicked up to Ogyen Trinley Dorje and his Chinese followers back in India.

The powers that be in India sided with Tenzin Chonyi, and Bardor Tulku resigned from KTD’s board of directors.

In retaliation KTD’s board banished Bardor Tulku from teaching there or at any of its affiliate centers, what his supporters refer to the “night of long knives”, which is the point in this story where Marvin Moser asked me to blog about what happened.


Filed under Buddhism

How China ended up recognizing reincarnation of popular teacher of Buddhism living in Australia…

Exhibit A: Palpung Australia

Just follow the money and the truth shall set you free

Leave a comment

Filed under Buddhism

Australian Karma Kagyu bought and paid for by Situ Rinpoche’s Chinese followers

After HHK16 passed in 1981 Situ Rinpoche violated his samaya and collaborated with the Chinese to make OTD 17th Karmapa, just follow the money Australia, and the truth shall set you free.

Leave a comment

Filed under Buddhism

Karma Kagyu Sect laundering Chinese money in New Zealand

This has nothing to do with the dharma.

New Zealand’s largest Tibetan Buddhist monastery, it sits on an 11-acre site and includes a more than 3000 square metre, three-storey temple, or gonpa​.

The whole facility will have cost about $11 million to construct when finished by the end of 2018.

And everything to do with laundering Chinese money.


Filed under Buddhism

Speaking as a lama about Leonard Cohen’s “I’m ready to die” moment 

“I am ready to die” Leonard Cohen Huffington Post

I’m at a celebration of a friend’s father’s 99th birthday…

He liked that I wore my bowler hat

It reminded him of when he was a child…

I’m reminded of
Leonard Cohen’s bad back which is so killing him at 82 years of age

I’ll leave it to practitioners of Zen to drill down into what he put his body through over the years…

I’m glad to have had a Karmapa who didn’t admire the Chinese like the current one does

Broke with tradition, passed into Parinirvana here rather than in Sikkim, India…

So I didn’t have to cripple myself to see the true nature of my mind


Filed under Buddhism

A year without China’s Karmapa in America 

Westbound Lawrence Avenue in Uptown neighborhood…

OTD has some explaining to do…

The Panama papers

His using the same law firm as CCP members to hide Kagyu Monlam money in offshore account

Jamgon Kongtrul the 4th

His trafficking, endangerment, and abuse of children

The Denzong Lhadey in Sikkim

His machinations on behalf of his Chinese followers against Indian rule in Sikkim

It is no coincidence OTD didn’t visit us this year…

This is a victory for our Karma Kagyu crazy wisdom lineage

Say no to OTD and his
Chinese followers…

Karmapa chenno


Filed under Buddhism

Ogyen Trinley Dorje nous a montré qui il est … Ogyen Trinley Dorje has shown us who he is 

Une femme en attente d’un bus à Clark et Belmont à Lakeview Quartier …

A Woman waiting for a bus at Clark and Belmont in Lakeview Neighborhood

Je vous dis que nous devrions le croire …

I say to you we should believe him

Il est qu’il est …

It is that it is

Ses disciples aussi …

His followers too

Ils ne vont nulle part …

They aren’t going anywhere

Leave a comment

Filed under Bouddhisme, Buddhism

Le 16ème Karmapa a fui les Chinois … The 16th Karmapa fled the Chinese 

Maître de la retraite dans la fenêtre en regardant son esprit …
Master of retirement in window watching his mind

Le 17ème Karmapa admire les Chinois …

The 17th Karmapa admires the Chinese

Ogyen Trinley Dorje est sur le mauvais côté de l’histoire …

Ogyen Trinley Dorje is on the wrong side of history


Filed under Bouddhisme, Buddhism

Business as usual pour le courant Labrang de Jamgon Kongtrul … Business as usual for Jamgon Kongtrul’s current Labrang 

De la “Journée de la beauté” au salon de l’ami à Barrington, Illinois …

From “Day of beauty” at friend’s salon in Barrington, Illinois

Ceci est sur Orgyen Trinley Dorje et ses disciples chinois …

This is on Ogyen Trinley Dorje and his Chinese disciples

Ce que la vie dans une dictature est comme …

What life is like in a dictatorship

Leave a comment

Filed under Bouddhisme, Buddhism

Penser comme un lama à propos de Donald Trump et l’élection 2016 … Thinking like a lama about Donald Trump and the 2016 Election 

À Granville et Sheridan Road conduisant déjeuner à Tweet est l’autre jour …

At Granville and Sheridan Road driving to breakfast at Tweet’s the other day

Je me demande ce que serait Khenpo Tsultrim Gyamtso Rinpoché pense de cette Octobre surprises …

I ask myself what would Khenpo Tsultrim Gyamtso Rinpoche think of this October of surprises

Où est Ari Goldfield quand nous avons besoin de lui ?…

Where is Ari Goldfield when we need him

De toute façon !


Je me rappelle le charnier …

I am reminded of the charnel ground

La mort du status quo politique d’une génération …

The death of the political status quo of a generation

Et la joie de la vie de Rinpoché …

And Rinpoche’s joy of living

Emaho !



Filed under Bouddhisme, Buddhism